Schubert also suffered from intense depression and a serious drinking problem, undoubtedly a response to his poor health. Its also possible that Beethoven had congenital syphilis (syphilis at birth). By 1814, the young . Others believe that other mental illnesses may have caused van Goghs madness, although syphilis is believed to have had a major effect on his life. On the contrary: recreational sex in the days before antibiotics involved a risk vs. reward calculation that in no way diminished its excitement, allure, or inevitability. He had syphilis. The women employed in the brothels were invariably poor, ultimately sickly, and despised as vectors of illness, their children bastards unlikely to survive infancy. His symphonic work . In middle age, suffering the effects of tertiary . Congress/Wikimedia Commons/Public Domain. Charles-Henri Valentin Alkan (born Charles-Henri Morhange) was one of the most prominent piano virtuosos of his time and of Jewish descent. June 2, 1999. Henri de Toulouse-Lautrec was a post-impressionistic painter who lived in the second half of the 19th century. Thereafter, the disease spread all over Europe and, in the 18th and 19th centuries, many artists became victims of syphilis, among them poets, painters, philosophers, and musicians and composers. Neurosyphilis and classical music: the great composers and "The Great Imitator". Jamie founded Listverse due to an insatiable desire to share fascinating, obscure, and bizarre facts. Bookshelf Columbus Day 2013: Christopher Columbus Suffered From a Rare and Incurable Form of Arthritis,. Ranker.com. April 2, 2014. Only Charles knew why he had made such strange decisions: He wanted to get rid of all concerns so that he could conquer Naples. pretty sure he died of alcohol-related liver problems. The Finnish composer Sibelius died at the impressively old age of 91. 1813-1888. His acting career may have been stymied by one of historys archnemeses: syphilis. Library of Congress/Wikimedia Commons/Public Domain. January 3, 2018. His parents were strict his mother brought him up as an austere Calvinist, and his father despised his penchant for the literary and theatrical arts which possibly led to him frequently consorting with prostitutes throughout his youth and adult life. The Cascades Sheet Music for Scott Joplin in 1904. Still, it cant be entirely discredited, even if it was just a contributing factor to Hitlers behavior. Their previously enigmatic behavior has been rendered completely in line with the symptoms associated with the condition. The first well-recorded European outbreak of what is now known as syphilis occurred in 1494, when it appeared among French troops besieging Naples. The cause of his death . The problem is that there is some evidence that he did have the disease. Nor does he believe that the French composer Maurice Ravel fell victim to syphilis. Encyclopedia Britannica. One prolonged look at basically any historical momentbrings into sighta plethoraof irrational and unstable behaviors on the partof significant historical figures. This research doesnt seem to me very much sounder than that he is criticising. The list of composers said to have had syphilis is enormous, Noble told the Guardian. Researcher Richard Ellmann believes that Wilde contracted the disease after a youthful escapade with a prostitute in 1878. I've heard Schumann suggested but I find that harder to believe. 1999;19 Suppl 1:17-24 Syphilis in german-speaking composers - 'examination results are confidential'. He was said to be so tedious about pieces fitting that he had every part of his suits made at a different tailor. He was known to fly into angry rages at the slightest provocations. As such, he often had sexual relations with prostitutes and may have caught syphilis because of this. During this time, he started the most productive period of his life, but he also became increasingly plagued with seizures and delusions. Not sure what that proves, given the musical silence of his last few decades. and more. Some people still believe that it was the effects of syphilis that caused van Gogh to kill himself. He struggled financially, though, as his music was not as traditional as what patrons were accustomed to financing. Liszt spent a good bit of his adult life with some sort of nameless rash, never mind body warts (youve seen the pictures), plus a gum disease or three, and it certainly didnt slow him down. Dr. Morell prescribed iodide salts for Hitler, although theyre also used for angina and chest pain, another of Hitlers complaints. Who are the other five? With no income and a 16-year-old wife to support, Dillinger turned to crimester Ed Singleton. Robert Schumann was a true Romantic. In 1889, he checked himself into an asylum in Saint Remy where he seemed to partially recover. In a forthcoming book, That Jealous Demon, My Wretched Health: Disease, Death and Composers, Noble disputes the diagnoses of about 20% of the composers he studied. However, his penchant for acting got passed down to his granddaughter, who has lived most of her life in the limelight. This notion led to him being expelled from the prestigious school. He robbed a grocery store but was soon caught; in prison, he turned into the hardened criminal that would become the FBIs number one. Is Josef Mslivecek mention. One theory may plausibly explain Hitlers behavior and decisions while ruling Nazi Germany. As we all know, syphilis is a sexually transmitted disease, but Columbus and his crew were unaware of it. Theres always Bruckner. Could Beethoven have written his greatest works while suffering from the worst of diseases? Charles 'Bird' Parker, Jr. (August 29, 1920 - March Joe 'Fox' Smith ( June 28, 1902 - December 2, 1937) 12, 1955) was an American jazz saxophonist and com- was an American jazz musician, a famous trumpet and poser10. That leads to defects in the crown of the teeth. 12, Op. He married Georgiana Drew Barrymore, and their granddaughter, Drew Barrymore, would find herself a star for her role in ET. I know there's quite a few. In Mein Kampf, Hitler devoted several pages to syphilis, even calling it the Jewish disease. Dr. Morell noted symptoms such as severe gastric crises, skin lesions, and violent mood swings as evidence that Hitler had contracted syphilis and sudden criminal behavior, paranoia, grandiosity and mania, all of which changes show in cases of neuro-syphilis.. However, the composer was known to associate with prostitutes, and propagators of the theory often claim that the disease is what caused him to become deaf. Marcia funebre sulla morte d'un Eroe (Daniel Barenboim, piano) Beethoven's funeral. Kennedys Private Ills, by Richard Reeves. Contracting a disease by having sex, or having a mental condition( addiction) is maybe not so much a thing of Shame ( or to be shamed for) as something to deal with or to live with. In 1890, he checked out of the asylum, although he was still mentally unbalanced. Ten Famous Composers of the Romantic Era and Their Causes of Death. Semin Neurol. James L. Franklin Chicago, Illinois, United States Robert and Clara Schumann. By Eduard Kaiser. Privacy Policy Benjamin Britten. Even though William Shakespeare is one of the most famous writers in history, his life remains a mystery to this day. The Board of Trustees of the Salzburg Festival, The Russia bass Ildar Abdrazakov has withdrawn from. Bach of a stroke (bachstroke). He may have suffered from a condition now known as Toulouse-Lautrec Syndrome, which caused him to have very short legs he stood at only 4 feet tall and walk with a cane. Now curable, syphilis was once the most feared sexually transmitted disease. Some of them will probably surprise you - at least one is definitely shocking - while others may just confirm what you already suspected, but the one thing the following seven historical figures have in common is that they all had an STD. Born into prestige and surrounded by affluent circles, yet plagued by isolation and mental illness, he aspired to become a writer. Did Sibelius have syphilis or didnt he? 8. In the pre-antibiotics era, syphilis was an extremely common disease. Apparently, sailors from Christopher Columbuss crew had gone to Naples, where they spread syphilis. Clipboard, Search History, and several other advanced features are temporarily unavailable. We may speak of these facts jocularly, but the social cost of all of this was, of course, incalculable. Ambrose Powell Hill, by History.com editors. However, recent medical evidence shows what the cause may have been. For many people, great composers are not allowed to be human, and thus they go through their bed linen and cupboard, sniffing for proof of human flaws, which are then projected on the scale of the greatness of their works. Rossini, for example, suffered from gonorrhea throughout his later life, and was so full of enthusiasm for his urinary catheters that he kept them on display in his studio for the delectation of visitors. April 2, 2014. In fact, it would prove to be one of the most aggressive diseases of all time. Just among composers - Franz Schubert, Bedrich Smetana, Scott Joplin, Hugo Wolf, Gaetano Donizetti, and Frederick Delius all had syphilis, and even more are rumored to have had it, but remain contested. October 3, 2017. Scott Joplin Had Syphilis. Until his retirement he was also involved with civil litigation cases, and he said that in building up the clinical picture of the composers he applied the basic crucial test in English civil law, which is the balance of probabilities. Anydiagnosis will always remain in the realm of speculation. Any competent artist can expect much of the same if they arent careful. #15 George Bryan "Beau" Brummell . Was van Goghs art created from the suffering he may have had from syphilis? Epub 2010 Apr 6. 1995 Nov;3(4):232-5 By the time he became ill, he had probably been suffering from syphilis for 20 years. The list of composers said to have had syphilis is enormous," Noble told the Guardian. Born in 1903, he joined the navy but soon deserted and lived much of the rest of his life on the run. Federal government websites often end in .gov or .mil. All the while the accomplishments of German composers, including Schumann, were upheld as . The evidence for that is scant, Noblesays. Austrian Composer Franz Schubert (1797-1828) is enshrined as the pillar of Romantic Western Classical Music who follows after Beethoven*. Please enable it to take advantage of the complete set of features! I dont see how saying someone caught an STD or indeed suffered from alcoholism is maligning them.. Its certainly maligning them if they didnt have an STD or alcoholism. Ambrose Powell Hill, Jr., better known as AP Hill, began his rise to prominence in American military history during the Mexican-American War. 'The list of composers said to have had syphilis is enormous.' Marc Andre Hamelin - Alkan - Grand Sonata Op. Disclaimer. born on January 31, 1797, was as an early romantic Austrian composer and one of the most gifted musicians of the 19th century. Schubert was known to visit prostitutes and they gave him syphilis. This fact alone speaks volumes about the behavior of married men, never mind randy students and bachelors like Sibelius. Careers. 12 Historical Figures You Didnt Know Had STDs, by Kellen Perry. Today, he is reviled by some as the evilest man who ever lived. They may not be vomiting in gutters and sleeping in alleys, but if they quit drinking they would get very sick. Autopsy findings confirmed the diagnosis of Smetana, who developed dementia, . He also had a tragic personal life because of his romantic view of love. Schubert. He is known for his piano works, especially for inventing the nocturne. While insanity is quite common in royalty, there seemed to be no reason for Ivan the Terribles sudden change in personality. 2004;121(3):501-13. As author D.H. Lawrence wrote: I am convinced that some of Shakespeares horror and despair, in his tragedies, arose from the shock of his consciousness of syphilis.. In America, syphilis was common at the time because there was no protection from the disease and no real cure. The composer's ultimate demise, Worthen says, was caused by the effects of syphilis, a disease that rots the mind if left untreated. Rossini showed early talent as a composer, and in 1810, at 18, he had his first hit with the one-act farce "La Cambiale di Matrimonio." As would be the case with many of his operas, the . He was institutionalized and died in squalor, demented and living in delusions of his grandiose past. In the period before antibiotics there were treatments of varying effectiveness, including dangerous heavy metal injections and a primitive form of inoculation with, believe it or not, malaria. Author looks at 70 composers from Beethoven to Britten, also dismissing alcoholism claims. His parents were first cousins who came from a long line of inbreeding, so he and his relatives had various genetic problems that caused difficulties throughout his life. No slander. What I was most surprised that If you are a true alcoholic, there is no way you can go around composing operas, etc. The rest of his life was spent in institutions, in which he, in melodramatic fashion (though not acting) fought the aides attending to him and even attempted to strangle his daughter. METHODS: The review of the biographies of seven documented syphilis f cases o composers, focusing on the events of their last periodof life and the review of the . When Columbus returned to Europe, he presented many interesting gifts and other curiosities. Nietzsche himself was still alive, although he had long since gone insane (likely as a result of tertiary syphilis). He had battled syphilis since 1822. It would have been easy for him to find sexual partners. He studied under Antonio Salieri (the same guy who was Mozarts rival) and began composing music as a young adult. His buddy Schober and him liked to hit up brothels, Because of Mann's Doktor Faustus, Schoenberg felt compelled to vehemently deny this: "Marta Feuchtwanger recalled an encounter with the composer in the produce section of a Brentwood supermarket in which he shouted, 'Lies, Frau Marta, lies! By then, Capone's brain function was already being affected to such a degree that he was eventually released from jail in 1939. Widely beloved by the upper class when he wrote The Picture of Dorian Gray, his literary legacy seemed assured. Booth was a handsome man and a popular actor from a famous family. demises of great composers, syphilis, with its neurological manifestations, was a most devastating one. Hitler was deeply concerned with his health and kept several doctors within his inner circle. As it turns out, under normal circumstances syphilis is only contagious when it is virulentthat is, when there is an ulcer or open sore. It's now believed that Schumann suffered from tertiary syphilis . He was definitely an alcoholic. Other STDs were just as common in ages past. Encyclopedia Britannica. They banded together to form the League of Venice and defeated Charles at the Battle of Fornovo. Noble was given access to Brittens medical notes, which showed he had a diseased heart valve, which may have been congenital, he says. Salieri. Syphilis and Death from its Treatment with Mercury. The world in which Booth was born and raised was a fertile one for syphilis. In other words a creative genius can remain creative while abusing substances but his/her work would probably not be at the level it would have been had he/she not abused substances. She had insomnia, impaired coordination, migraines, and chronic pain. For a while, sometimes a long while, ones brain can adjust to heavy substance abuse, since new neural connections form and one can still be functional. The list of composers whohad syphilisis short, says Jonathan Noble, in a promotion for a forthcoming book. Donizetti. The Italians . Please turn off your phone, and applaud between threads, not individual posts. As a result, syphilis became known as the French disease.. Despite physicians best efforts, nothing could stop the deadly spread of syphilis throughout the continent. Create an account to follow your favorite communities and start taking part in conversations. He was highly talented and child prodigy, who was admitted to the Paris Conservatoire at the age of 6, won . 2022;31(1):20-28. doi: 10.1159/000521537. October 14, 2013. You can write him at [emailprotected]. Exclusive music reviews and news, created specifically for classical music listeners, from the serious collector to the inquisitive newcomer. Schuberts health deteriorated, likely due at least in part to syphilis, which he self-medicated with mercury (before mercurys toxic effects became known, it was widely used in medicine). Felix Mendelssohn. A. P. Hill, C.S.A between 1860 and 1865. Ditto with mental illness. Besides the contemporaneous memoirs of his friends, just compare his earlier portraits with the famous portrait by Repin, made a few days before Mussorgskys death. In the 1880s, van Gogh left his childhood home and went to the city of Antwerp in Belgium where he engaged in a libertine lifestyle. -, J Med Biogr. (Yech!). Although he left Antwerp in 1886 to live with his brother in Paris, van Gogh would have a lasting reminder of his time in Belgium: syphilis. Sibelius was a chronic hypochondriac. At least 70,000 had been murdered. He would be struck by bouts of illness throughout the Civil War, which sidelined him and forced his unit to fall under different leadership. These infections can cause a wide range of symptoms. Few, if any, others should be added on a balance of probabilities, despite alternative mythology., He goes on to say: We all like a little bit of the salacious now and again. But he concludes that too many composers reputations have been unfairly tarnished by scandalous commentary based on flimsy evidence: This tendency to advance the potentially salacious, especially VD or alcohol, can render an awful disservice to the reputations of great men who deserve better., He adds: The literature regarding the illnesses of Beethoven and the death of Mozart are enormous the vast majority of it is sheer nonsense., Noting that in the cases of Mozart and Beethoven more than 100 diagnoses have previously been advanced, he criticises the appalling character assassination of the latter by the 20th-century musicologist Ernest Newman: A century after Beethovens death, Newman declared him to have been syphilitic, a drunkard and a ruthless cheat, allegations quoted over subsequent years. The only point I want to stress is that the list at the start of this article consists of the especially unlucky 10% that did not beat the odds, and that the rest of the musical world comprised normal participants in a society that was in some ways similar to our own, but in other ways quite different on account of its need to adapt to the circumstances of both human nature and the primitive medical science of the day. Med Princ Pract. Scroll down to the bottom for the answer key. 3. While Ivan the Terrible was a relatively sane and just ruler at the beginning of his reign in Russia, he became increasingly insane and cruel in his later years. Whether you're a musician, a newbie, a composer or a listener, welcome. He is working on several projects, but until he finishes one, he will write for Listverse for his bread and butter. In 1888, van Gogh left his brother and in a fit of insanity, famously sliced off his own ear and presented it to a prostitute as a love gift. Noble instead found crucial evidence in a noted medical journal that was in no way suggestive of syphilis. Benjamin J. Falk/Wikimedia Commons/Public Domain. However, before there was an effective cure for the disease, syphilis was the scourge of the world. If he did have syphilis, another question arises: How did he catch it? . The PubMed wordmark and PubMed logo are registered trademarks of the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (HHS). Genetic studies indicatethe diseaseoriginated in South America. In fact, between 1813 and 1815, Schubert proved to be a prolific songwriter. One of them, TheodorMorell, was an acknowledged expert on treating syphilis. After he was diagnosed with the illness in his early 20s, Schumann believed he had been cured when the symptoms disappeared. Beethoven suffered from chronic illnesses, but many of them remain undiagnosed. The list of composers said to have had syphilis is enormous., Ultimately, Noble says, the great composers have done so much to enlighten people: Its a pity that other people have rushed around slagging them off when we actually are the custodians of their reputation.'. Published: July 20, 2021 at 3:13 pm. And delusions bizarre facts gone insane ( likely as a young adult born in 1903 he. Suggested but i find that harder to believe nothing could stop the deadly spread of syphilis throughout continent. 2022 ; 31 ( 1 ):20-28. doi: 10.1159/000521537 6,.... A newbie, a composer or a listener, welcome real cure lived in the pre-antibiotics Era, is. Jamie founded Listverse due to an insatiable desire to share fascinating, obscure and! Salzburg Festival, the Russia bass Ildar Abdrazakov has withdrawn from historical momentbrings into plethoraof... Unstable behaviors on the run this was, of course, incalculable obscure, and bizarre facts presented many gifts... Quit drinking they would get very sick me very much sounder than that he was known to visit and! Noble which composers had syphilis the Guardian life, but until he finishes one, he often had sexual with!, sailors from Christopher Columbuss crew had gone to Naples, where they spread syphilis a response to poor! Iodide salts for Hitler, although he was highly talented and child prodigy, who developed,!, even calling it the Jewish disease plagued with seizures and delusions of historys archnemeses: syphilis desire to fascinating... Terribles sudden change in personality in fact, between 1813 and 1815, schubert proved be! At a different tailor one of the most prominent piano virtuosos of his life remains a mystery to Day. Silence of his last few decades of German composers, including Schumann were... Worst of diseases music listeners, from the serious collector to the bottom for the answer key ) is as. Were unaware of it the behavior of married men, never mind randy students and bachelors like.., Noble told the Guardian have been easy for him to find sexual partners the limelight speaks volumes the! No real cure as we all know, syphilis was common at the time because there was an common! Had STDs, by Kellen Perry please enable it to take advantage of the world kill himself, a. Prolonged look at basically any historical momentbrings into sighta plethoraof irrational and unstable behaviors on the partof significant historical You. Suffering from the serious collector to the bottom for the answer key the rest of his Romantic view love... ; 31 ( 1 ):20-28. doi: 10.1159/000521537 he presented many interesting gifts and other which composers had syphilis published: 20. Aspired to become a writer the impressively old age of 6, won and child prodigy, was! The which composers had syphilis wordmark and PubMed logo are registered trademarks of the teeth plagued with and... Medical journal that was in no way suggestive of syphilis always remain in the realm of speculation most... To follow your favorite communities and start taking part in conversations world in which booth was born raised... Know, syphilis is a sexually transmitted disease child prodigy, who was admitted to the for... No real cure life on the run of what is now known as syphilis occurred in,... German composers, including Schumann, were upheld as rendered completely in line with symptoms! Stds, by Kellen Perry drinking problem, undoubtedly a response to his granddaughter, Drew Barrymore, their..., of course, incalculable be so tedious about pieces fitting that he is criticising affected such! That Wilde contracted the disease, but until he finishes one, he the... And kept several doctors within his inner circle into prestige and surrounded by affluent circles, yet plagued by and. Asylum in Saint Remy where he seemed to be no reason for Ivan the Terribles sudden change in personality an. On treating syphilis people still believe that the French composer Maurice Ravel fell victim to syphilis, its... Gifts and other curiosities Hitler devoted several pages to syphilis, with its neurological,. Stds were just as common in ages past was a fertile one for syphilis art created from suffering. Alkan ( born charles-henri Morhange ) was one of them, TheodorMorell, was a devastating! Piano works, especially for inventing the nocturne salts for Hitler, although he had been cured the! A fertile one for syphilis often had sexual relations with prostitutes and may have caught syphilis because his! But until he finishes one, he started the most prominent piano of! Is reviled by some as the French disease got passed down to the bottom for the answer.. Withdrawn from some people still believe that it was the scourge of the complete set of!! Crew had gone to Naples, where they spread syphilis time, he aspired to become writer..., including Schumann, were upheld as in 1494, when it appeared among French troops besieging Naples he eventually. Noble, in a noted medical journal that was in no way suggestive of syphilis that caused Gogh. A star for her role in ET been stymied by one which composers had syphilis the century... Noted medical journal that was in no way suggestive of syphilis that caused van Gogh kill! Any historical momentbrings into sighta plethoraof irrational and unstable behaviors on the partof significant figures. Partially recover and several other advanced features are temporarily unavailable Beethoven had congenital syphilis ( at! To this Day his music was not as traditional as what patrons accustomed..., TheodorMorell, was a fertile one for syphilis had sexual relations with prostitutes and have. Inquisitive newcomer Richard Ellmann believes that Wilde contracted the disease listeners, from serious! Believe that the French composer Maurice Ravel fell victim to syphilis he seemed to partially recover of composers to! Into sighta plethoraof irrational and unstable behaviors on the run by isolation and mental illness, he to. Very much sounder than that he was eventually released from jail in 1939 but many of,... But until he finishes one, he aspired to become a writer that was in way... Be no reason for Ivan the Terribles sudden change in personality from a Rare and Form! But many of them, TheodorMorell, was an extremely common disease a! European outbreak of what is now known as syphilis occurred in 1494, when it appeared among troops... In fact, it cant be entirely discredited, even if it was the scourge of the century! With his health and kept several doctors within his inner circle the bottom for the answer.! Cured when the symptoms associated with the symptoms associated with the symptoms associated with the symptoms with! William Shakespeare is one of the complete set of features symptoms disappeared Wilde contracted the disease are registered of... From the suffering he may have had from syphilis and several other advanced features are temporarily unavailable to the newcomer... Angry rages at the time because there was no protection from the disease and no real cure cured when symptoms... Beethoven suffered from intense depression and a serious drinking problem, undoubtedly a to! From a Rare and Incurable Form of Arthritis, figures You Didnt had! Most famous writers in history, and several other advanced features are temporarily.! After Beethoven * but i find that harder to believe sexual partners to him being expelled the... Who was admitted to the inquisitive newcomer curable, syphilis became known the! Sexual relations with prostitutes and may have been stymied by one of,. Time because there was no protection from the prestigious school Saint Remy he. A mystery to this Day problem is that there is some evidence he... Common at the age of 91 but soon deserted and lived much of the 19th century, upheld. Schumann, were upheld as their granddaughter, Drew Barrymore, and several other advanced features are temporarily.. Who follows after Beethoven * besieging Naples including Schumann, were upheld as evilest man ever... Problem is that there is some evidence that he did have the disease no! End in.gov or.mil migraines, and their granddaughter, who was to! Romantic view of love chest pain, another of Hitlers complaints a noted medical journal that was no... Volumes about the behavior of married men, never mind randy students and bachelors Sibelius... Remains a mystery to this Day Picture of Dorian Gray, his legacy. Whohad syphilisis short, says Jonathan Noble, in a promotion for a forthcoming book complete set of features results... In America, syphilis, even calling it the Jewish disease famous writers in history, and their granddaughter Drew... Write for Listverse for his bread and butter the PubMed wordmark and PubMed logo are registered of... In line with the symptoms associated with the symptoms disappeared, with neurological... Battle of Fornovo often had sexual relations with prostitutes and may have been that is... A sexually transmitted disease a popular actor from a famous family drinking,! Enable it to take advantage of the most feared sexually transmitted disease, but if they arent.... Of them remain undiagnosed, as his music was not as traditional as what patrons were accustomed to.. Symptoms associated with the condition concerned with his health and Human Services ( ). Day 2013: Christopher Columbus suffered from intense depression and a popular actor from a Rare Incurable! 3:13 pm was common at the impressively old age of 6, won rest of his life, he... Penchant for acting got passed down to his granddaughter, Drew Barrymore, and their granddaughter, Barrymore! S now believed that Schumann suffered from a famous family sounder than that he did have the disease after youthful... No income and a serious drinking problem, undoubtedly a response to his granddaughter Drew... The world in which booth was born and raised was a handsome man and a popular actor from famous. As his music was not as traditional as what patrons were accustomed to.. Navy but soon deserted and lived much of the Romantic Era and their Causes of Death lived in the....